Book Talk Thursday: Carlisle and Edward

This weeks book talk question revolves around the dynamic between Edward and Carlisle.

Do you think Carlisle did the right thing changing Edward? Do you think it was a selfish choice? Do you think Edward shows signs of resenting being changed by Carlisle? In the end do you think Edward is happy he was changed? Explain.

Discusss… discuss… discuss…

Image courtesy of Twilightguide.com

book talk: the cullens

Oops, I forgot about this today. But I’m back and ready to go.

So here is my question. Do you think the Cullen’s really blend in at high-school? I know for the books sake they do just enough to attend school but do you think that’s plausible? If you think it’s not what would you change about the books to make it more plausible?

Book Talk: Rosalie

This weeks book talk question focuses on the relationship between Rosalie and Bella.

Is Rosalie’s dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?

Do you think her reaction to Bella is purely selfish or is she really reacting out of loyalty to her family?

Alright ladies, let her have it.

---

Be sure to enter this months drawing for Blog Candy!! And head on over to the discussion board to talk more about the books, photos, Rob and the weekly challenges.

Book Talk: Edward’s Attraction

I found a lovely sight FULL of question about Twilight so I’m going to throw one out today that I thought was sort of unique.

Edward is ferociously attracted to Bella by her smell. That may make his love unconditional (because she can’t change the smell of her blood), but does it make it less admirable since it’s not based on character?

What do you ladies (and gents) think about this? I’d honestly never thought about it until I read the question and then was suddenly intrigued.

Book Talk: Edward versus Rob

Let’s have a friendly debate today, you know you want too….

Edward versus Rob. Who do you pick?

What did you think I was going to say Edward versus Jacob? I know better than to go there.